Free initial phone consultation:  (08) 9328 5662

Major Structural Defects and REIWA Annexure A: What Building Elements are Included?

Major structural defects and REIWA Annexure A:  What building elements are included?

The “Major Structural Defect” annexure in REIWA standard form residential sale contracts (REIWA Annexure A) is designed to give purchasers a short grace period to engage a building inspector to identify serious structural risks and issue a notice requiring a seller to rectify any major structural defects, failing which the purchaser may terminate the contract.

The REIWA Annexure A requires the purchaser to expressly state what other structures are incorporated, otherwise the inspection will only include the residential building, that is, the house.

The ambiguity in REIWA Annexure A involves:

    1. what is the definition of a “residential building”; and,
    2. is the residential building limited to physical portions of the building; or,
    3. does the building include other structures which:
      1. materially support the building’s foundations; and,
      2. are not physically connected to the building?

Vogt Legal recently represented a plaintiff suing a building inspector for failing to identify a major structural defect with a retaining wall.

In the decision of White v Staples t/as Jim’s Building Inspections (Duncraig) [2026] WADC 49 (White v Staples):

    1. the plaintiff purchasers did not expressly incorporate the retaining walls into the inspection of the residential building. After settlement of the sale, the retaining wall catastrophically collapsed;
    2. the plaintiff purchasers argued that by virtue of a pre-purchase building inspector’s failure to identify major structural defects in a retaining wall, the purchasers suffered loss and damage, being the costs of replacing the retaining wall; and,
    3. the defendant building inspector argued that the wall was not part of the “residential building” and as such, the plaintiffs would never have had the right to issue a major structural defects notice under REIWA Annexure A.

The defendant argued that there was no obligation to identify such defects because the retaining wall was not part of the residential building as defined under REIWA Annexure A.  In this respect, many purchasers assume that their structural inspection includes structures such as fencing, sheds, carports and the defendant’s interpretation would exclude those structures from the definition of residential building under REIWA Annexure A.

However, Vogt Legal advanced the position that:

    1. Clause 3.2.1 of section 3 of AS 4349.1 – 2007, which was incorporated into AS 4349.1 – 2007, expressly required the inspector to inspect retaining walls within 30 metres of the residential building; and,
    2. on the basis of an independent engineer’s evidence, the retaining wall is taken to be of the residential building and the foundations of the residence, where it:
      1. is within the zone of influence of the residence; and,
      2. retains the soil on which the residence is constructed.

The District Court’s judgment in White v Staples was made in the context of a costs application following a failed summary judgment application made by the defendant, and did not involve making a binding decision as to the correct interpretation of REIWA Annexure A.

Nevertheless, the Court’s comments made in passing were that where a purchaser does not expressly refer to retaining walls in REIWA Annexure A, a purchaser may be precluded from contending that retaining walls fell within the scope of REIWA Annexure A.

The case for a broader interpretation

Purchasers are encouraged to obtain independent legal advice before entering into a contract to purchase residential property, with a view to ensuring that the meaning of “residential building” in REIWA Annexure A is adequately defined.  

Conclusion

White v Staples underscores that critical inspection rights depend on the inclusion and interpretation of a few words under a contract.  

If “residential building” is construed narrowly, retaining wall failures may fall outside the major structural defects regime under REIWA Annexure A.  

However, retaining wall failures may fall within the major structural defects regime under REIWA Annexure A, when considering:

    1. the express wording of AS 4349.1 – 2007; and,
    2. the integral role of retaining walls in supporting the structures of residential buildings.

Get in touch today for a free initial legal consultation.

This article/post is provided for general information purposes only and does not constitute any Legal Advice. It does not take into account your objectives, instructions or all of the relevant facts and/or circumstances. Will Vogt or Vogt Legal accepts no responsibility to any persons who relies on the information provided on this website.