Can Your Strata Company Make You Replace Your Apartment Flooring?
Can Your Strata Company Make You Replace Your Apartment Flooring?
Replacing carpet with modern flooring can be an effective way to update an apartment. But if you own a strata apartment in Western Australia, choosing new flooring is not always as simple as selecting a product and arranging installation.
Your strata scheme's by-laws may restrict the types of flooring you can install, require approval before work begins, or impose requirements designed to minimise noise travelling between apartments.
A recent decision of the State Administrative Tribunal highlights the potential consequences of getting this wrong.
A flooring upgrade that resulted in a replacement order
In The Owners of Island Strata Plan 43285 and Negria [2026] WASAT 122, the Tribunal considered a dispute about flooring installed in an apartment in a Mosman Park residential building.
The relevant strata by-law was in the following terms:
27. Floor Coverings
A proprietor or occupier of a lot shall take all reasonable steps to reduce impact noise throughout the area of the lot of which they are the proprietor and will install floor coverings that comprises carpet on a thick underlay to ensure compliance with the impact isolation of footfall noise, and shall not install any other form of upper surface floor covering without submitting plans and specifications thereof to the strata company and obtaining approval of the strata company in writing.
The Respondent apartment owner replaced the existing broadloom carpet with carpet tiles laid over plastic sheeting and rubber-like interlocking mats. The strata company had not approved the new flooring system.
The owner argued that the flooring consisted of carpet tiles over underlay and complied with the by-law.
The Tribunal was not satisfied that the new floor covering in the respondent's unit is 'carpet on a thick underlay' within the meaning of the by‑law. Rather, the Tribunal found that the floor covering is an 'other form of upper surface floor covering' within the meaning of the by-law, and therefore it could only be installed with the prior approval of the strata company.
The Tribunal ultimately ordered the owner to remove the flooring system and install a new flooring system which complied with the by-law.
What if the previous owner installed the flooring?
The decision also highlights a potential issue for apartment purchasers.
The parties were in dispute as to whether the underlying materials had been installed by the owner or whether they were already present when he purchased the apartment. The Tribunal found it unnecessary to resolve that dispute because the relevant by-law imposed obligations on the current owner regardless of who had installed the flooring.
The decision serves as an important reminder that a new owner may become responsible for ensuring compliance with a strata by-law immediately upon acquiring a property, including in relation to existing installations. If a new owner discovers that an existing feature of the property does not comply with a by-law, they should obtain legal advice to determine whether they may have recourse against the seller under the contract of sale or otherwise.
Can the strata company force you to replace flooring?
Under section 47 of the Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA), a strata company may apply to the State Administrative Tribunal for an order enforcing scheme by-laws where the applicable statutory requirements are satisfied.
Depending on the circumstances, the Tribunal can order an owner to take action to remedy a contravention.
In the Negria decision, the owner estimated that replacing the flooring with broadloom carpet and commercial underlay would cost approximately $4,677. The Tribunal nevertheless considered the cost reasonable in the circumstances and not disproportionate or unduly burdensome.
The Tribunal also considered the importance of owners complying with by-laws intended to protect the amenity of the building for the benefit of other owners and occupiers.
This means that the cost of removing and replacing flooring is not necessarily enough to avoid a rectification order.
However, an alleged breach does not automatically entitle a strata company to every order it requests. The Tribunal must consider the applicable legal requirements and exercise its discretion in the circumstances of the case.
What should you do before changing your flooring?
If you own a strata apartment in Western Australia and are considering a flooring upgrade, there are several practical steps worth taking:
- Check your strata by-laws. Identify any restrictions on flooring materials, underlay, noise reduction and renovations.
- Confirm whether approval is required. If the by-laws require written approval, obtain it before installing the new flooring.
- Provide the relevant specifications. Product descriptions alone may not establish that a proposed flooring system satisfies the by-laws. Installation instructions and technical information may also be important.
- Do not assume an existing arrangement is compliant. If you are purchasing an apartment, investigate whether the existing flooring was approved where required.
- Seek advice if a dispute arises. If your strata company alleges a breach or demands that you replace flooring, or any other component of your property, obtain advice about your obligations and the options available before the dispute escalates.
This article/post is provided for general information purposes only and does not constitute any Legal Advice. It does not take into account your objectives, instructions or all of the relevant facts and/or circumstances. Will Vogt or Vogt Legal accepts no responsibility to any persons who relies on the information provided on this website.

Author
Ben Sasson's areas of expertise
Published in: Articles
Share
More articles by Ben Sasson
- Do I Have to Let My Builder Fix Defects? A Guide for Homeowners in WA
- Can You Make an Adverse Possession Claim Over Part of a Strata Lot in Western Australia
- Can Strata Companies Use a Different Builder to Fix Defects? Rectifying Common Property Defects in WA
- Green Title, Built Strata and Survey Strata— What’s the Difference?
- Home and Land Packages – Every Rose has its Thorns
- My Building Inspector Failed to Report a Defect in the Pre-Purchase Inspection Report. Can I Recover my Financial Loss From the Building Inspector?
- VIDEO: Important announcement regarding Nicheliving's deregistration
- Nicheliving’s Registration Expiry Does Not Void Your Building Contract
- Caught in the Middle: Homeowners’ next steps after Nicheliving’s failure to renew building contractor registration
- Considering a Class Action Lawsuit Against a Builder or Building Group: Practical Insights
- Your Trusted Partner in Resolving Construction Disputes
Latest articles
- Major Structural Defects and REIWA Annexure A: What Building Elements are Included?
- Can Your Strata Company Make You Replace Your Apartment Flooring?
- Civil Contractors & Difficult Clients
- Do I Have to Let My Builder Fix Defects? A Guide for Homeowners in WA
- Can You Make an Adverse Possession Claim Over Part of a Strata Lot in Western Australia